Read by chief executives, M&A advisers, equity analysts and general counsel. Their lawyers read it in six-minute increments. Yours is free

Till Vesting Do Us Part

Paul Tyler’s Double Down bonus is still at the altar. Meet its sister.

Illustration for Till Vesting Do Us Part, Side Letter's piece on the Superloop AGM vote on Paul Tyler's SuperCharge grant
The ring from last time is still in the post. Illustration: Unaudited.
Ryan Tan
Ryan Tan20 Nov 2026

At every wedding the celebrant asks whether anyone knows a reason these two should not be joined, then leaves a pause that nobody, in the long history of matrimony, has ever been foolish enough to fill.

Superloop's shareholders fill it every two years. In November 2024, 18.6 per cent of votes went against Paul Tyler's Double Down Growth Incentive. On Thursday, 17.2 per cent went against his SuperCharge Growth Incentive, on the same morning that 98.8 per cent waved through the remuneration report describing it.

Spare a thought for the Double Down grant, which is still standing at the altar. It needed $700 million of revenue in a year. Superloop managed $664.3 million, and has since bought two businesses.

The objection was noted and the vows went ahead. The ring from last time is still in the post.


One in Six

Superloop lodged the results of its annual general meeting on Thursday 19 November.

The remuneration report passed with 98.81 per cent of votes in favour and 1.19 per cent against. That is about 4.9 million votes out of roughly 415 million cast, a number large enough to have its own postcode and small enough to round to nothing.

Resolution 6, the grant of 1,224,799 performance rights to Paul Tyler under the SuperCharge Growth Incentive, passed with 82.79 per cent. Against it were 71.5 million votes, or 17.21 per cent.

Shareholders were asked, on the same morning, how Superloop pays its managing director, and whether it should pay him this. The answers differed by sixteen points.

Two years ago they differed by about the same.

At the 2024 meeting the remuneration report drew 2.24 per cent against. Mr Tyler's annual grant of performance rights drew 16.42 per cent against, and his grant under the Double Down Growth Incentive drew 18.64 per cent.

The objection turns up for the special occasions. Illustration: Unaudited.

This post is for subscribers only

Already have an account? Sign in.
Filed beside the deal.

Side Letter

Short items on what was agreed beside the deal. The announcement has the headline. We have the terms. Every side letter, filed in one place.

Further disclosures

View all →

Subscribe to Unaudited

Don’t miss out on the latest issues. Sign up now to get access to the library of members-only issues.
jamie@example.com
Subscribe

Praised by Jason Paris (former CEO, One NZ)and James Linton (ex-Exetel).Cited by The Firm, read by 32,000 accountants.Featured by Xero’s Singapore Partner of the Year.