Read by chief executives, M&A advisers, equity analysts and general counsel. Their lawyers read it in six-minute increments. Yours is free

Nine Or Ten

If you enjoyed your meal, tell your friends. And ProductReview.

Illustration for Nine Or Ten: the sequence from Swoop's 'when appropriate' in 2025 to its stated setting, a ProductReview invitation for NPS scores of 9 or 10 only
The question, and the number at the end of it. Illustration: Unaudited.
Ryan Tan
Ryan Tan9 Nov 2026

There is a sign you see in pubs and cafés, chalked up near the till. If you enjoyed your meal, tell your friends. If you didn't, tell us. Nobody has ever objected to it, because the arrangement is written on the wall.

In November 2025 the Australian Financial Review asked Swoop Holdings why its ProductReview page had collected hundreds of mostly positive reviews in a matter of months. The chief executive said any suggestion the company was paying for them was simply untrue, and that Swoop asked customers for reviews when appropriate.

On 9 November 2026, asked a narrow question by email, the company explained what that means. A nine or a ten on its NPS survey gets you the option. Anything lower goes into a recovery process.

Somebody has finally written it on the wall.


A question was put to Swoop Holdings on 4 November. One question, narrow, arising out of one of the ten answers the company had already given in writing.

It asked whether the ProductReview prompt is shown to every customer who completes an NPS survey, or only to those scoring at or above a threshold, and from what date.

The company answered on 9 November, inside the deadline it was given. It is published in full at the foot of When Appropriate.

That is twice now, both in writing, both on time. It is worth saying plainly that almost no company does this once.


The thing that was never explained

On 27 November 2025, Hannah Wootton wrote in the Financial Review's Rear Window column that Swoop's ProductReview page had put on about 900 reviews since it was last cached in August, nearly all of them positive, an increase of more than forty per cent. She reported that many came from unverified accounts with a first name, no photograph and nothing else ever reviewed. The rating sat at 4.8 and went on a slide at that year's annual general meeting.

Those observations are hers. Unaudited has not gone back and checked them, and nothing in this piece should be read as doing so.

Alex West, then the chief executive, told her the suggestion that Swoop was paying for reviews was simply untrue. He said the increase reflected customer growth, and that since April 2024 the company had run a deliberate strategy of delivering the best service it could and then, when appropriate, asking for reviews.

When appropriate did a great deal of work in that sentence and nobody has explained it since.

This post is for subscribers only

Already have an account? Sign in.
Filed beside the deal.

Side Letter

Short items on what was agreed beside the deal. The announcement has the headline. We have the terms. Every side letter, filed in one place.

Further disclosures

View all →

Subscribe to Unaudited

Don’t miss out on the latest issues. Sign up now to get access to the library of members-only issues.
jamie@example.com
Subscribe

Praised by Jason Paris (former CEO, One NZ)and James Linton (ex-Exetel).Cited by The Firm, read by 32,000 accountants.Featured by Xero’s Singapore Partner of the Year.